Building Pathways That Work: A Principal's Guide to CTE, Dual Credit, and Career Readiness
A practical guide to five program structures that prepare students for both college and careers: CTE programs of study, dual enrollment, industry certifications, work-based learning, and career academies.
When I walked into a career academy classroom for the first time, I expected to see students building things. I did not expect to see them presenting portfolio defenses, explaining their project timelines, and quoting industry standards the way my best AP English students quoted Shakespeare.
That was the moment I understood CTE is not a separate track for students who are not going to college. It is a different approach to the same goal: readiness.
This article is for administrators who want to understand what the program structures actually look like, which ones the research supports, and how to build or strengthen these pathways in their buildings. It focuses on five core program structures: CTE programs of study, dual enrollment and dual credit, industry-recognized certifications, work-based learning, and career academies.
The earlier article "Career Readiness in Every Classroom" covered what teachers can do in their classrooms to build career-ready skills. This article is about the program-level structures that make those efforts possible in the first place.
What the Data Says About CTE Participation
Career and Technical Education is not a small program. It is a major part of American secondary education. According to the U.S. Department of Education's National Center for Education Statistics, approximately 8.3 million high school students, or about 77 percent of all high school students, take at least one CTE course before graduation (NCES). The question is not whether students are in CTE. It is whether their CTE experience is structured as a coherent pathway or a random collection of courses.
The difference matters. Students who concentrate in a CTE program of study, meaning they complete two or more courses in a single career cluster, have significantly higher graduation rates than students who do not. A study using data from the High School Longitudinal Study of 2009 found that CTE concentrators had a graduation rate of 94 percent compared to 86 percent for students who were not CTE concentrators (Brunner et al. 14). That gap persists across demographic groups and is largest for students from low-income backgrounds where the difference between concentrators and non-concentrators exceeds 10 percentage points.
The research also shows CTE concentrators are no less likely to enroll in postsecondary education than their peers (Carnevale et al.). The notion that CTE tracks students away from college is not supported by the data. CTE concentrators enroll in college at comparable rates, and they are more likely to be employed after graduation regardless of whether they attend college.
The takeaway for administrators is straightforward. A disconnected CTE course here and there does not move the needle. A coherent CTE program of study does.
Programs of Study: The Backbone of CTE
A program of study is a coordinated, non-duplicative sequence of academic and technical content that leads to an industry-recognized credential or a postsecondary degree. It is the organizational unit that turns a collection of courses into an actual pathway.
Under the federal Strengthening Career and Technical Education for the 21st Century Act (Perkins V), every state receiving federal CTE funding must offer at least one program of study in each of the 16 career clusters defined by the National Career Clusters Framework. These clusters range from Agriculture, Food and Natural Resources to Information Technology to Health Science to Transportation, Distribution, and Logistics.
Each program of study includes four key components:
- Secondary and postsecondary coursework aligned to industry standards
- Academic content integrated with technical content
- Opportunities for dual or concurrent enrollment
- Leads to an industry-recognized credential, certificate, or degree
The Association for Career and Technical Education (ACTE) recommends that schools design programs of study around local labor market demand. A school in a region with a growing healthcare sector, for example, should build its Health Science pathway with an eye toward the specific certifications and credentials that local employers require and the specific postsecondary programs that lead to employment in that field (ACTE).
Dual Enrollment and Dual Credit: The College Connection
Dual enrollment is one of the most researched interventions in secondary education, and the findings are consistently positive.
The Community College Research Center (CCRC) at Columbia University has conducted multiple studies on dual enrollment and found that students who participate in dual enrollment programs are more likely to graduate high school, enroll in college, and persist in college to completion (Fink, Jenkins, and Yanagiura). A CCRC study using data from the National Student Clearinghouse found that dual enrollment participants had a college enrollment rate of 80 percent compared to 72 percent for non-participants, and their college persistence rate was four percentage points higher.
The effects are particularly strong for students from low-income backgrounds and students of color. CCRC research found that dual enrollment reduced racial and socioeconomic equity gaps in college access by a statistically significant margin (Fink, Jenkins, and Yanagiura).
Minnesota is a national leader in this area through its Postsecondary Enrollment Options (PSEO) program. Created in 1985, PSEO allows 10th, 11th, and 12th grade students to enroll in college courses at Minnesota public institutions tuition-free while earning both high school and college credit. According to the Minnesota Department of Education, over 30,000 Minnesota students participate in PSEO annually. The Minnesota Office of Higher Education has found that PSEO participants are more likely to enroll in a Minnesota college after high school and complete a degree within four years than their peers who did not participate.
For administrators, dual enrollment is not just a program. It is a college access strategy that the research consistently supports.
| Dual Enrollment Outcome | Participant Rate | Non-Participant Rate | | :--- | :--- | :--- | | College Enrollment (any postsecondary) | 80% | 72% | | College Persistence (year 1 to year 2) | 78% | 74% | | High School Graduation | 93% | 87% |
Source: Fink, Jenkins, and Yanagiura, CCRC, 2017
Industry-Recognized Certifications
Industry-recognized certifications are portable credentials that verify a student has mastered the skills required for a specific occupation. They are distinct from academic credentials because they are developed and awarded by industry organizations, not educational institutions.
Common examples include CompTIA A+ and Network+ for information technology, NCCER certification for construction trades, Certified Nursing Assistant (CNA) for healthcare, Adobe Certified Professional for creative fields, and ASE certification for automotive technology.
The research on industry certifications in high school is developing but promising. A study on Florida's CAPE Act found that students who earned industry certifications in high school had higher employment rates and earnings after graduation than demographically matched peers who did not (Dougherty et al.). The effects were largest for certifications in high-demand fields like information technology and health sciences.
For principals, the key question is which certifications to prioritize. Not all certifications carry equal weight. The National Skills Coalition recommends that schools focus on certifications that:
- Are recognized by multiple employers in the local labor market
- Lead to jobs with family-sustaining wages
- Stack toward higher-level credentials
- Are portable across employers
One certification planning strategy is to audit your local labor market data. Identify the top five industries in your region, the entry-level credentials those industries require, and the postsecondary programs that lead to those credentials. Then align your certification offerings accordingly. A certification that no local employer recognizes is not serving your students.
Work-Based Learning: Beyond Job Shadowing
Work-based learning (WBL) encompasses a range of structured experiences that connect classroom instruction to real-world work environments. The spectrum includes job shadowing, internships, cooperative education, registered apprenticeships, and youth apprenticeships.
The research is clearest on the most intensive end of the spectrum. Registered apprenticeships, which combine paid on-the-job training with related classroom instruction, have the strongest evidence base. The U.S. Department of Labor reports that 93 percent of apprentices who complete a registered apprenticeship retain employment with an average annual wage of over $80,000 (U.S. Department of Labor).
For high school students, youth apprenticeships and paid internships show strong outcomes. A study by the Education Development Center found that students who participated in paid work-based learning experiences during high school were more likely to graduate on time and more likely to be employed six months after graduation than students who did not participate (EDC). The effects were largest when WBL experiences were connected to a coherent program of study rather than standalone placements.
ConnectED, a national nonprofit that supports career pathways, has documented that the most effective WBL programs share three characteristics: they are aligned to classroom instruction, they are paid rather than unpaid, and they include a structured reflection component that helps students connect their work experience to their academic learning.
For administrators, WBL is the hardest program structure to build because it requires employer partnerships that take time and trust to develop. The most successful approach is to start with one industry sector, build deep partnerships with two or three employers, and expand from there. A school that tries to offer internships in every field at once will end up with shallow partnerships that do not serve students well.
Career Academies: The Integrated Model
Career academies are the most comprehensively researched program model in career readiness education. A career academy is a school-within-a-school structure that combines a college-preparatory academic curriculum with a career-themed curriculum and work-based learning experiences, typically organized around a single career theme.
The MDRC study of career academies remains the gold standard. Kemple conducted a random assignment study involving over 1,400 students across nine career academies and followed participants through their mid-twenties. The results were striking. Career academy participants earned 11 percent more annually than control group members over an eight-year follow-up period. For young men, the earnings impact was 17 percent (Kemple, ES-ES8).
The MDRC study also found that career academies increased the likelihood of living independently with children, suggesting that participants achieved greater family stability. Importantly, the study found no evidence that career academies reduced college enrollment. Career academy participants were equally likely to attend college as control group members, and they earned more when they entered the workforce, regardless of whether they went to college.
The Linked Learning approach in California, which extends the career academy model to entire school districts, has been studied by SRI International. SRI's evaluation found that students in Linked Learning pathways had higher graduation rates, higher rates of A-G course completion (California's college readiness curriculum), and higher rates of AP/IB participation than comparison students in traditional high school programs (SRI International).
For principals, career academies represent the most comprehensive career readiness model available. They require significant staff coordination, schedule flexibility, and employer partnerships, but the research shows they produce results that no standalone program can match.
What This Means for Your Building
The research on career readiness programs points to five conclusions that I think every principal should carry into their planning:
-
Coherence matters more than course count. A student who takes three unrelated CTE courses is not in a pathway. The program of study structure is what produces the graduation and employment outcomes the research documents.
-
Dual enrollment is the most scalable college access strategy. It works across demographic groups, it is supported by decades of research, and Minnesota already has the infrastructure through PSEO. The question is whether your students know about it and whether your schedule enables it.
-
Industry certifications should drive curriculum, not the other way around. Starting with a certification and building a course around it is backward. Start with local labor market demand, identify the credentials that matter, and build the pathway from there.
-
Work-based learning must be paid to be equitable. Unpaid internships privilege students who can afford to work for free. If your WBL program is unpaid, you are likely serving students who already have advantages. Paid placements serve all students.
-
Career academies work, but they are not cheap to start. The MDRC study showed long-term earnings gains of 11 percent. But career academies require dedicated staff, common planning time, industry partnerships, and a scheduling structure that supports team teaching. Treat it as a multi-year investment, not a one-year initiative.
The Objection I Hear Most
We are not a career and technical school. We are a comprehensive high school. Our mission is college readiness.
I hear this frequently. Here is what the data says. Eighty-three percent of high school students take at least one CTE course. Seventy-seven percent of parents say they want their children to have career preparation in high school. The CEOs of Apple, Google, and Microsoft have all spoken publicly about the value of career and technical education.
College readiness and career readiness are not opposed to each other. The most effective programs, the ones that MDRC studied in career academies and that SRI studied in Linked Learning, combine both. Students in these programs go to college at the same rates as their peers and earn more when they leave.
You do not have to choose. You have to integrate.
Works Cited
Association for Career and Technical Education (ACTE). "What Is CTE?" ACTE Online, www.acteonline.org/why-cte.
Brunner, Eric, et al. "The Impact of Career and Technical Education on High School Graduation and Postsecondary Outcomes." CALDER Working Paper, No. 279-1023, 2023.
Carnevale, Anthony P., et al. "Career and Technical Education: Five Ways That Pay." Georgetown University Center on Education and the Workforce, 2012.
ConnectED. "The Essential Elements of Work-Based Learning." ConnectED National, 2020.
Dougherty, Shaun M., et al. "The Distribution of Industry Certification Benefits Across Student Subgroups: Evidence from Florida." Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, vol. 43, no. 2, 2021, pp. 293-316.
Education Development Center (EDC). "Work-Based Learning in Massachusetts: An Analysis of Student Outcomes." EDC, 2019.
Fink, John, Davis Jenkins, and Takeshi Yanagiura. "What Happens to Students Who Take Community College Dual Enrollment Courses in High School?" Community College Research Center, Columbia University, 2017.
Kemple, James J. "Career Academies: Long-Term Impacts on Labor Market Outcomes, Educational Attainment, and Transitions to Adulthood." MDRC, 2008.
Minnesota Department of Education. "Postsecondary Enrollment Options (PSEO) Program." education.mn.gov.
Minnesota Office of Higher Education. "Postsecondary Enrollment Options Program Evaluation." 2019.
National Center for Education Statistics (NCES). "High School Longitudinal Study of 2009 (HSLS:09): CTE Participation and Postsecondary Outcomes." U.S. Department of Education, 2023.
National Skills Coalition. "The Role of Industry Credentials in Career Pathways." National Skills Coalition, 2021.
SRI International. "Linked Learning Evaluation: Final Report." SRI Education, 2021.
U.S. Department of Labor. "Registered Apprenticeship: The Gold Standard." Apprenticeship.gov, 2024.