← Instructional Leadership

The First Ten Minutes: What Walkthroughs Really Tell Us

September 14, 2025·7 min read

A short visit can surface more than a scripted observation. Backed by research, here is how to make every minute of a walkthrough count and what to do after you leave the room.

When I step into a classroom, I am not there to evaluate a lesson plan. I am there to learn what students are experiencing in that moment. That distinction matters more than most administrators realize.

A walkthrough is not a formal observation. It is not a checklist. It is a snapshot of teaching and learning in real time, and research shows that when done consistently, these short visits improve both instruction and school culture. City, Elmore, Fiarman, and Teitel described instructional rounds as a practice that shifts the focus from evaluating individual teachers to understanding the instructional core, what students are doing, what teachers are doing, and what the work actually requires (City et al. 8). When administrators see enough classrooms, patterns emerge. A struggling third period across three different teachers is not three individual problems. It is a scheduling problem, or a support problem, or a curriculum problem. The key word is frequent. One walkthrough a semester is a check box. Three a week is a culture.

This article is about what I look for in those first ten minutes and what the research says about why it works.

Why Walkthroughs Work

The best walkthrough research starts with a simple idea: you cannot lead what you do not see. City, Elmore, Fiarman, and Teitel described instructional rounds as a practice that shifts the focus from evaluating individual teachers to understanding the instructional core, what students are doing, what teachers are doing, and what the work actually requires (City et al. 8). When administrators see enough classrooms, patterns emerge. A struggling third period across three different teachers is not three individual problems. It is a scheduling problem, or a support problem, or a curriculum problem.

Downey and colleagues argue that walkthroughs are most effective when they are reflective rather than evaluative. The goal is not to catch someone doing something wrong. It is to gather data that leads to better questions in the follow-up conversation (Downey et al. 22).

What I Watch For

I structure the first ten minutes around three questions:

  1. What are students being asked to do? Not what is written on the board. Not what the teacher is saying. What the task actually requires. If I can describe the cognitive demand in one sentence, the lesson has clarity. If I cannot, that tells me something too.

  2. Who is doing the cognitive lifting? If I am following only the teacher's voice for ten straight minutes, the students are passengers. Fisher and Frey describe this as the gradual release of responsibility model: the teacher models, then guides, then the student works independently (Fisher and Frey 6). A walkthrough should show movement through that arc. If it does not, the lesson may be heavy on telling and light on learning.

  3. What is the room telling me? Posted work, student seating, engagement in the corners, the temperature of the room. These signals are data. A wall full of worksheets from August sends a different message than exemplary student work with rubrics attached.

A walkthrough is not a verdict. It is a conversation starter.

The Right Frequency Matters

One of the most common mistakes administrators make is treating walkthroughs as a compliance task. You do three a year because the district requires it. That is not enough.

City, Elmore, Fiarman, and Teitel recommend that administrators conduct frequent, focused instructional rounds to build a reliable picture of instruction across the school (City et al. 33). At that volume, patterns become visible. You can tell which departments are using common assessments, which teachers are struggling with pacing, and where professional development is actually landing.

Feedback That Sticks

Here is the part most of us get wrong: the visit matters less than what happens after.

I leave a short note the same day. One specific strength. One honest question. The strength tells the teacher I was paying attention. The question tells them I am thinking with them, not about them.

Marzano found that feedback is most effective when it is timely, specific, and focused on the task rather than the person (Marzano 82). That is what a good walkthrough note does. It is not a performance review. It says: I saw this. I wondered about that. Let us talk when you are ready.

The question is the part teachers remember. It signals that I am invested in their growth, not just their compliance.

Building a Walkthrough Culture

Walkthroughs only work when teachers trust the process. That means they need to be predictable, low-stakes, and frequent. Teachers should not brace themselves when you walk in. They should barely look up.

Here is what builds that trust:

  • Go every week, not just when there is a problem. If you only show up after a parent complaint, the walkthrough becomes a punishment.
  • Leave a note every time. Even if it is two sentences. Consistency signals that you value the work.
  • Keep the conversation separate from evaluation. If every walkthrough ends up in a formal file, teachers will close their doors. Walkthroughs are for coaching. Evaluations are for accountability. Do not mix them.

City and her colleagues write that the most powerful instructional rounds happen in networks where trust is high and the goal is collective improvement, not individual judgment (City et al. 136). That same principle applies to walkthroughs in a single building.

The Bottom Line

The first ten minutes of a walkthrough can tell you more about a school than a full period of formal observation. But only if you know what to look for and what to do with what you see.

Students working. Teachers guiding. Cognitive demand visible in the task. That is what I am looking for. When I see it consistently across rooms, I know the instructional leadership is working. When I do not, I know where to focus my time next week.

Walkthroughs are not about catching bad teaching. They are about understanding what teaching looks like in your building so you can lead it better.

Works Cited

City, Elizabeth A., et al. Instructional Rounds in Education: A Network Approach to Improving Teaching and Learning. Harvard Education Press, 2009.

Downey, Carolyn J., et al. The Three-Minute Classroom Walk-Through: Changing School Supervisory Practice One Teacher at a Time. Corwin Press, 2004.

Fisher, Douglas, and Nancy Frey. Better Learning Through Structured Teaching: A Framework for the Gradual Release of Responsibility. 3rd ed., ASCD, 2021.

Marzano, Robert J. The Art and Science of Teaching: A Comprehensive Framework for Effective Instruction. ASCD, 2007.