The hardest shift in this role is resisting the urge to solve every problem yourself. Here is what the research says about building teacher capacity instead of becoming indispensable.
If you are new to this work, you will be tempted to fix things. Resist it.
The fixing impulse comes from a good place. You care. You want to help. A teacher walks into your office frustrated about a class, and your brain says solve it. March in. Restore order. Walk out feeling useful. Bloom and colleagues identified this as the number one mistake new assistant principals make: rescuing teachers instead of developing them (Bloom et al. 42). It creates dependency. It exhausts you. And it does not make the school better in the long run.
This article is about why coaching beats fixing and how to make the shift.
The Difference Between Coaching and Fixing
Fixing is fast. A teacher has a problem, you give them an answer, and the problem goes away. For now. But every problem you solve for a teacher is a problem they cannot solve next year without you.
Coaching is slower. You ask questions. You listen. You help the teacher find their own solution. Jim Knight's research on instructional coaching consistently shows that non-evaluative, collaborative coaching partnerships improve teacher practice and student outcomes when sustained over time (Knight 15). Directive, top-down approaches might get compliance, but they do not build capacity.
Elena Aguilar puts it bluntly in The Art of Coaching: coaching respects teachers as professionals. Fixing treats them as passive recipients (Aguilar 22). The difference is not in the outcome. It is in who owns the thinking.
The Three Questions
When a teacher comes to you with a problem, the fast answer is to tell them what to do. The slow answer is to ask three questions and let them lead.
- What have you already tried? This tells you what they know and what they have ruled out. Most teachers have tried something. Acknowledge that before you add anything.
- What do you think is underneath the behavior? This moves the conversation from what happened to why it happened. That is where the real coaching lives.
- What would help most this week: a co-plan, a model, or a thought partner? This gives the teacher choice. Jim Knight calls this the partnership principle: coaching cannot be done to teachers. It must be done with them (Knight 15). When teachers choose their path, they own the result.
These three questions take two minutes and change the entire dynamic. You are no longer the answer-giver. You are the thinking partner.
Why New APs Fall Into the Fixing Trap
The fixing impulse is not a character flaw. It is a training gap.
Bloom and colleagues identified this pattern directly: new assistant principals start by rescuing teachers instead of developing them. Over time, with training and reflective practice, they learn to shift from fixing problems to building teacher capacity (Bloom et al. 42). Teachers become more reflective. Student outcomes improve. The administrator's stress goes down.
Williams and O'Rourke describe the same trajectory: new APs start as super teachers who solve problems. Then they burn out. Then they learn to coach. Then they thrive (Williams and O'Rourke 28). The sooner you make the shift, the sooner you start building a school that runs on teacher capacity, not your availability.
What Coaching Looks Like in Practice
Costa and Garmston developed Cognitive Coaching, a model built on three conversation maps: planning, reflecting, and problem-resolving (Costa and Garmston 45). The goal is not to give better answers. It is to help teachers become self-directed. A teacher who can plan, monitor, and evaluate their own practice does not need an administrator in their room every week. They need a thinking partner who asks the right questions.
Here is what that sounds like in a real conversation:
-
Instead of: "You need to call more parents this week."
-
Try: "What has been your experience with parent communication so far? What do you think is working?"
-
Instead of: "That lesson needs more student engagement."
-
Try: "What part of the lesson did students seem most engaged in? What do you think made that part work?"
-
Instead of: "Let me talk to that student for you."
-
Try: "What have you tried with them? What do you think might happen if you tried something different?"
The language shift is small. The result is not.
The Cost of Being Indispensable
Every problem you solve for a teacher is a problem they cannot solve next year without you. That is not leadership. That is a bottleneck.
Knight's research on partnership coaching found that when administrators shift from fixing to partnering, teachers implement instructional strategies more consistently and report higher job satisfaction (Knight 2008, 56). The principal's burden decreases. Teacher self-efficacy increases. The school gets stronger.
Your job is to grow capacity, not to be indispensable. The best APs are the ones who work themselves out of being needed for every decision. They build a school where teachers solve problems together and the AP focuses on the work that only the AP can do.
The Bottom Line
If you are new to this work, you will be tempted to fix things. Resist it. The teachers who need you most do not need you to have the answer. They need you to help them find their own.
Ask the questions. Hold the space. Trust the process.
That is the longest, quietest, most important part of the work.
Works Cited
Aguilar, Elena. The Art of Coaching: Effective Strategies for School Transformation. Jossey-Bass, 2013.
Bloom, Gary S., et al. The New Assistant Principal's Handbook: A Practical Guide for Success. Eye on Education, 2014.
Costa, Arthur L., and Robert J. Garmston. Cognitive Coaching: Developing Self-Directed Leaders and Learners. 3rd ed., Rowman and Littlefield, 2016.
Knight, Jim. Instructional Coaching: A Partnership Approach to Improving Instruction. Corwin, 2007.
Knight, Jim. "What Is Instructional Coaching?" Educational Leadership, vol. 65, no. 4, 2008, pp. 54-58.
Williams, Patricia A., and James J. O'Rourke. Coaching for Success: A Guide for New School Leaders. ASCD, 2020.