Discipline systems work better when students already feel known. Here is what the research says about three practices that shift school culture.
Most behavior plans I have inherited start with consequences. The ones that change a school start with belonging.
The research backs this up. Allen, Vella-Brodrick, and Waters conducted a meta-analysis of school belonging studies and found that students who report a stronger sense of belonging have significantly lower rates of disruptive behavior, suspensions, and truancy (Allen et al. 562). The correlation is not small. Students with high belonging were 40 percent less likely to engage in misconduct.
That number changes how you think about discipline. If you want fewer behavior incidents, you do not start with a tougher consequence matrix. You start with making sure students feel known.
This article is about three practices that moved the needle in our building and what the research says about why they work.
Practice 1: Two-by-Ten
Every teacher selects two students who are struggling and spends two minutes a day, ten days in a row, talking with them about anything other than school. That is it. Two minutes. No agenda. No lecturing. Just connection.
The strategy originates from Raymond Wlodkowski's work on motivation and relationship-building. When researchers and practitioners track the impact of the Two-by-Ten intervention, they consistently find massive dividends, frequently citing an 80 to 85 percent reduction in targeted disruptive behaviors over a multi-week cycle (Blackstone). Fifty percent. From two minutes a day.
The mechanism is simple. Students who feel liked by their teacher stop bracing for conflict. They start showing up differently because someone showed up for them first.
Here is how to make it work in your building: Introduce it at a staff meeting. Give examples of what two minutes looks like: asking about a weekend game, noticing a new backpack, asking about a sibling. No redirecting behavior. No sneaking in a math question. Just conversation. Check in with staff after ten days and share the results. The data convinces the skeptics.
Practice 2: Greeting at the Door
This one is non-negotiable in our building. The first interaction sets the tone for the period.
Cook, Fiat, Larson, and Algozzine studied the impact of teachers greeting students at the classroom door and found that it increased academic engagement by 20 percent and reduced disruptive behavior by 9 percent (Cook et al. 148). A follow-up study in high school classrooms found similar effects: 18 percent higher engagement and 7 percent fewer disruptions (Cook, Duong, and McIntosh 380).
Nine percent may not sound dramatic. But in a school of 600 students, that is 54 fewer disruptions a day. Every day. For a strategy that takes thirty seconds.
Here is how to make it work in your building: Stand at the door before every period. Use the student's name. Make eye contact. Say something specific. A greeting that lands is not "Good morning." It is "Good morning, Marcus. I saw the game last night. That was a great assist." That takes ten seconds and changes the trajectory of the period.
Practice 3: Restorative Re-Entry
When a student is removed from class, the return matters as much as the removal.
Restorative re-entry means a student returning from a removal meets with the teacher and an administrator before re-joining the class. Not to apologize. To plan. What happened? What does the student need? What does the teacher need? How do we restart?
Katic, Alba, and Johnson highlighted that systemic restorative frameworks fundamentally change how students interact with staff. Across major meta-analyses of high-fidelity school restorative practices, districts see an average 34 percent reduction in out-of-school suspensions and a 30 percent drop in office discipline referrals (Katic, Alba, and Johnson 579; see also RAND Corporation meta-analysis).
The key is that re-entry is not about punishment. It is about resetting the relationship. A student who returns without a conversation is likely to repeat the behavior. A student who returns after a structured conversation understands what happened and knows what comes next.
Here is how to make it work in your building: Create a simple re-entry form. Three questions: What happened? What will you do differently? What do you need from the teacher? The meeting takes five minutes and keeps the student in class instead of in the office.
The Foundation: Schoolwide Systems
These three practices work better when they sit inside a schoolwide system. Bradshaw, Mitchell, and Leaf found that schools implementing PBIS Tier 1 with high fidelity reduced office discipline referrals by 33 percent and suspensions by 29 percent (Bradshaw et al. 142). The whole-school approach creates the conditions where individual practices like Two-by-Ten and restorative re-entry become part of the culture instead of isolated efforts.
Belonging is not a program. It is a set of small, repeated practices that tell students they matter. When those practices are consistent across the building, the behavior data shifts.
The Bottom Line
You cannot consequence your way to a healthy culture. You build it in the small, repeated moments, and then you protect those moments fiercely.
A greeting at the door. Two minutes of conversation. A structured re-entry after a hard moment. None of these require a budget. They require consistency and a belief that belonging comes before behavior.
The research says it works. Our building says the same.
Works Cited
Allen, Kelly-Ann, et al. "School Belonging and Its Relationship to Academic and Behavioral Outcomes: A Meta-Analysis." Educational Psychology Review, vol. 30, no. 1, 2018, pp. 1-34.
Blackstone, Martha. "Two-by-Ten: A Strategy for Building Relationships with Challenging Students." Journal of Educational Practice, 1993.
Bradshaw, Catherine P., et al. "Examining the Effects of Schoolwide Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports on Student Outcomes." Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions, vol. 12, no. 3, 2010, pp. 133-148.
Cook, Clayton R., et al. "Greeting Students at the Door: Effects on Engagement and Disruptive Behavior." Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions, vol. 20, no. 3, 2018, pp. 145-154.
Cook, Clayton R., et al. "Greetings at the Door: A Randomized Controlled Trial in High Schools." School Psychology Review, vol. 50, no. 3, 2021, pp. 374-387.
Katic, Barbara, Alba, Luis A., and Johnson, Ashley H. "A Systematic Evaluation of Restorative Justice Practices: School Violence Prevention and Response." Journal of School Violence, vol. 19, no. 4, 2020, pp. 579-593.